Flatey Pizza
Restaurant in Reykjavík
The Reykjavík Grapevine · Best of Reykjavík 2026: Best Pizza

About Flatey Pizza
Winner of “Best Pizza” 2026. Flatey may have slipped on our list recently, but they are back and how! “No matter other pizzas, this is the one my family remains loyal to,” confessed one panellist. Try the tang-tinged crust, the bare-bones San Marzano tomato sauce true to its Neopolitan roots and that signature leopard spotting. The Umberto is a sublime take on flavours locals love, but the pizza biancos are especially noteworthy.
- Local favorite
- Neapolitan pizza
- Wood-fired pizza
- Pizza
- Group-friendly
- Lunch
- Dinner